Summary
The White Paper Canon Academic (WPCA) is a coherence-first framework developed to address a recurring and underexamined failure mode in complex intelligent systems:
As systems scale in capability, internal coherence degrades faster than corrective mechanisms can resolve—unless a sufficiently coherent foundation is present.
This pattern appears across biological, social, economic, and technical systems.
In artificial intelligence, it is uniquely amplified, because AI systems scale rapidly, generalize broadly, and are becoming tightly coupled to human decision-making infrastructure.
WPCA does not propose a new model architecture, training method, or governance regime.
It addresses a more fundamental question:
What structural conditions are required for intelligence—human or artificial—to remain stable, adaptive, and non-collapsing under scale?
The Core Observation
Increased capability does not guarantee increased stability.
As intelligent systems grow more capable, they often exhibit:
These phenomena are typically framed as alignment, safety, or governance problems.
WPCA argues that such framings treat symptoms rather than cause.
The underlying issue is coherence.
What WPCA Means by Coherence
In WPCA, coherence is a structural property—not a metaphor and not a value judgment.
A coherent system is one in which:
Such systems can adapt without destabilizing themselves.
Incoherent systems may continue functioning temporarily, but accumulate latent failure modes that eventually cascade under real-world complexity.
What Is Structurally New Here
Most contemporary AI safety and alignment approaches operate downstream of causation.
They attempt to constrain outcomes through values, objectives, policies, or oversight after a system’s causal structure is already fragmented.
WPCA addresses a different layer.
Its central contribution is the identification of fragmented causality as the upstream failure mode shared across instability, drift, misalignment, and escalating oversight costs—and the specification of unified (sole) causality as a minimal architectural condition required for coherence to persist under scale.
This is not a behavioral claim, ethical preference, or governance prescription.
It is a structural requirement.
Where coherence is discussed elsewhere, it is typically treated as an emergent or desirable property.
WPCA treats it as a necessary consequence of correct causal sourcing.
What WPCA Is — and Is Not
WPCA is:
WPCA is not:
WPCA does not rely on belief, values, or consensus.
It relies on structural necessity.
Status
WPCA is an active research and inquiry framework.
It is being refined, stress-tested, and extended across domains.
This page is offered as a point of entry, not a conclusion.
-
Copyright © 2025 David Waterman Schock. All rights reserved.
Authorship & Process Note
This work was developed through an iterative human–AI collaboration.
David Waterman Schock defined the conceptual framework, constraints, and claims; guided structured dialogue; evaluated outputs; and performed final selection, editing, and integration.
Large language models were used as analytical and drafting instruments under human direction.
All arguments, positions, and conclusions are the responsibility of the author.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.